Opening opportunities, closing old stereotypes

Jan. 1, 2020
Women still have to contend with industry's 'boys' only attitude

How many guys reading this can remember attending a crowded event with a woman and having to wait outside a restroom for her because the line at the women’s room was so long? Have you ever thought of the woman’s perspective? With my warped sense of humor, I commonly note that the lines in the women’s restrooms at national collision industry events are virtually non-existent. On a serious note: Why is that?

Most of the folks I’ve met during my 15-year involvement in the collision repair industry are baby boomers. We have witnessed and participated in major social changes in our country and around the world. Personally, my family gave me culturally acceptable advice about professional opportunities while growing up. I was told that I could consider the following career paths: nurse (I hate blood); secretary (I was a lousy typist and didn’t want an “office” job) or teacher (too tame, I thought). I considered go-go dancing and becoming a stewardess as options. Each seemed to offer a little excitement and both were somewhat exotic in nature. Unfortunately, being under the 5-foot, 2-inch tall requirement in those days disqualified me for the latter. As for the go-go dancer option, it took more guts than I had at the time. Regardless, I was not willing to accept limited options.

In contrast, today’s young women are taught that they can achieve whatever they want. Their options are not limited by society. Our industry is one that has opened its doors—but it takes time. Additionally, the challenges in “making it” in predominantly male dominated professions are formidable. Sometimes, because of cultural training, whether it be the male or female influences, it is more difficult for women to “fit in” certain professions. While positive advances are continuously being made, getting beyond the “boys club” takes a lot of energy for a woman—often more than the professional abilities necessary to get a job done.

It is difficult to pinpoint exactly why it is challenging for women to integrate into historically male professions. What is certain, however, is that women need mentors and coaches to help them navigate the waters—especially if they want to participate at the leadership level. These mentors can be other women who have managed to overcome the hurdles or men who see the value in facilitating a potential top performer—whether the person be male or female.

What about those of us already here? Many of today’s successful women in our industry owe thanks to their husbands, fathers and brothers for helping them break into the business. Today, more and more women who did not come to the industry through family ties must figure out how to acclimate. Ironically, women involved and successful in our industry are often overlooked as owners, leaders and decision makers. We are occasionally snickered at because we demand the respect and consideration we deserve at trade shows, the bar, or when passing by the still present “girlie” calendars in the back. We miss out on deals made on the golf course or during a guy’s night out. These comments are not meant as complaints but realities. Everyone has challenges they must overcome. This is our reality.

Women are often cited as nurturing, patient, attentive to detail, multi-task and management oriented. These traits have been adopted as cultural necessities as American society and its families dramatically changed during the past 50 years. These traits have proven attractive to businesses that need to deal with tough employee and customer issues, while juggling multiple tasks.

Through the years I’ve discussed this topic with a few dozen women in this industry, often in that relatively empty women’s restroom. Every collision repair industry businesswoman I’ve spoken to is in agreement: As a female, it’s tough to join the boys club.

Whether you are male or female, it’s always nice to be invited to play and to be recognized for a job well done. With regard to the latter, Akzo Nobel deserves kudos. Every recipient awarded Most Influential Women (MIW) with whom I’ve spoken to has been deeply touched and honored by Akzo’s gesture. Add to that Akzo’s contributions to foster female participation in the industry with scholarships in honor of MIW recipients, and the gratification of achieving MIW status is great, indeed. It is a sense of having arrived, being on a team and being appreciated.

We all know that our industry is changing rapidly. In my humble opinion, helping women succeed will raise the bar for the entire industry. So, if you are a woman, seek out a coach or mentor. And, if you are a man, imagine our industry 10 or 20 years from now, both with and without women. If you think that more women filling a variety of jobs will make our industry better, lend a hand. But please remember, sometimes the mentoring and coaching we need is a little different from what you’d offer to the new guy who played on the high school football team.

Oh, and girls, look forward to the day you attend an industry event and have to wait in line at the restrooms….

About the Author

Karen Fierst

Karen Fierst has more than 25 years of experience in the automotive aftermarket, specializing in the U.S. and Chinese collision repair industries. After serving as Deputy Executive Director of the Certified Aftermarket Part Association, she founded KerenOr Consultants in 1998. KerenOr Consultants provides business, market and strategic development consulting services to all segments of the automotive aftermarket, government agencies and law firms. The company has provided U.S. Liaison services for the Taiwan Auto Body Parts Association (TABPA) for 14 years. She has written articles for a number of U.S trade publicationsShe is a well-known speaker at industry events in the U.S. and internationally, having presented at the International Body Shop Industry Symposium (IBIS) in France, England, Switzerland and Spain; Automechanika Shanghai and Malaysia; and at several conferences in China. She has received numerous industry awards, including the prestigious Most Influential Woman in the industry award presented by Akzo Nobel.

Sponsored Recommendations

ADAS Applications: What They Are & What They Do

Learn how ADAS utilizes sensors such as radar, sonar, lidar and cameras to perceive the world around the vehicle, and either provide critical information to the driver or take...

Banking on Bigger Profits with a Heavy-Duty Truck Paint Booth

The addition of a heavy-duty paint booth for oversized trucks & vehicles can open the door to new or expanded service opportunities.

The Autel IA700: Advanced Modular ADAS is Here

The Autel IA700 is a state-of-the-art and versatile wheel alignment pre-check and ADAS calibration system engineered for both in-shop and mobile applications...

Boosting Your Shop's Bottom Line with an Extended Height Paint Booths

Discover how the investment in an extended-height paint booth is a game-changer for most collision shops with this Free Guide.